Category: Trafford Council

  • Autumn Reflection

    Autumn Reflection

    It’s been a little while since I posted. Rehabilitation from a planned heart operation is progressing well. It’s not been pain-free, but the worst is over. I even (briskly) walked Kingsway Parkrun on Saturday.

    It’s six months since I stepped down as a councillor. It’s still good to be free, but I still live in Trafford. I still care about the place and still care about the services we have. 

    Those six months have been dominated by a few issues that are coming to a head in the autumn period: 

    Critical Ofsted inspection of Children’s Services 

    I want to give a brief summary of how it’s being addressed as far as we know. 

    Trafford’s finances  

    In hourly expectation of something turning up, Trafford’s leadership has said it doesn’t want Exceptional Finance Support to balance its books this coming year. Given that Trafford relies on Council Tax more than its neighbours, I think the clearance to raise the rate a little more should not be rejected so easily.

    RankLocal AuthorityBand D 2026/27
    1Stockport£2,618.90
    2Oldham£2,602.23
    3Rochdale£2,600.83
    4Salford£2,594.45
    5Bury£2,555.15
    6Tameside£2,447.21
    7Bolton£2,399.74
    8Manchester£2,312.04
    9Trafford£2,291.70
    10Wigan£2,152.68

     

    Council Meeting Arrangements – Are Trafford’s council meetings doing their job?  

    (spoiler alert) No! And they’re getting worse. 

    This is my opportunity to have a go at Trafford’s opposition parties. Why are they allowing it to happen?

    Children’s Services

    Ofsted’s rating for Trafford’s Children’s Services was Inadequate. This rating led to a political furore. Opposition parties called for an emergency meeting of council on the 26th August at which they called a vote of no confidence in Trafford’s leader of the council, Tom Ross. The opposition parties didn’t have sufficient votes to win the no confidence vote against the Labour majority, but they did manage to muster unity across the four parties; Conservatives, Lib Dems, Greens and Reform that they’d lost faith in Tom. 

    In outvoting the combined opposition vote, the Labour group managed to navigate the rocky political waters charged by the damning report, but it wasn’t a comfortable night. It has to be said that it wasn’t a particularly well informed night. The Conservatives charge was that in 2015 under their leadership, Children’s Services received an ‘Outstanding Rating’. Labour countered that a lot of money had been pulled by the Conservatives since then. The debate rarely got beyond the superficial point-scoring.  

    Children’s Services were never my expertise, but my understanding is that Trafford Council knew Ofsted were coming for an inspection and were not anticipating the criticism that was heading their way. A lot, maybe even the majority of areas had indeed improved since their last inspection. The problem area was what they call the ‘front door’. This is the pathway into the system. Referrals can come from the police, schools, families, the young person self-referring etc. It’s the most critical element within the system. 

    Jill McGregor, until recently Corporate Director of Children’s Services, acknowledged that they hadn’t been sufficiently curious in drilling down how the front door was performing in different scenario during their pre-Ofsted preparation. Ofsted came in June 2026 at a moment of peak demand. Looking at the figures, it does seem to have been freakishly high demand. That said, their procedures and protocols should have been able to cope and they should not have been overwhelmed. Ofsted found that there were young people put at risk by delays, wrong pathways and the system underperforming. I don’t know whether the freak increase in demand broke the system whilst Ofsted were watching, but it’s clear it should not have broken. 

    Jill McGregor has left her post. The emphasis has shifted from understanding what went wrong to building a system that would have met Ofsted’s requirements in June 26. It’s fairly predictable and I’m sure it will work as a short term remedy.

    My gut feeling is that we need to give greater emphasis on driving performance from the top. Trafford’s leadership both on the political side and in terms of the senior corporate leadership is tilted very much towards toward the super-sized Lego set aspects of council activity. It’s understandable that regionally important projects such as the stadium district and Carrington should get the attention of the leadership. The photo-opportunities of topping-out ceremonies in hard-hats and hi-vis, not to mention trips to Monaco, do amount to the glamourous side of local politics. However, I do think there’s a need to strengthen the leadership of the more prosaic performance aspects. Our chief executive, Sara Todd, was not challenged at all by scrutiny as regards to her oversight of the corporate leadership in Children’s Services. It has to be said Environmental Services got a very easy ride from scrutiny when they were before them the other week. It leaves the impression that services that operate on a day to day basis don’t get the attention they merit until something goes wrong.

    I would advocate appointing a second deputy leader to work alongside Tom Ross and Liz Patel to drive performance improvement. I think they need the status to drive this agenda in the corporate leadership team. In terms of spend, adult, children and environmental operations account for the bulk of spending, but they’re not receiving sufficient status within the council’s hierarchy. Both Manchester and Salford councils have two deputy leaders each, so I don’t believe it’s an outrageous proposal and I am convinced there’s sufficient talent within the Labour Group to deliver someone who can really raise performance within the council’s main departments whilst working alongside Tom and Liz. 

    Trafford’s Finances

    The latest report on how we’re coping in the current year came before the Council’s Executive yesterday.

    We’re half-way through the current year and we’re heading for a £6m overspend. There will be actions to try to bring this figure down, but it is on top of the £12m that Trafford was already borrowing to set the budget. 

    Listening to Monday’s Executive meeting. I’m not sensing there’s panic. There is mention of a £7.5m grant that does seem to have been pulled out of a hat by the Government to target councils receiving exceptional financial support. I didn’t see that coming, so there may be more. My biggest worry is meeting budget requirements via long-term debt. That debt is mounting. 

    We’ll see. The council are currently recruiting a successor to our Financial Officer, Graeme Bentley who is retiring. You’d assume that new finance officer would be looking to get things on a stable footing as quickly as possible. Graeme is an excellent officer and this isn’t how he’d want to leave things. I don’t think we can live in hope that something will turn up.

    Council Meetings

    Let’s keep this one short. Meetings of councillors have become rubbish and it’s the fault of councillors.  

    Tomorrow night’s meeting is scheduled to commence at 7pm and to finish at 9:30pm. 

    The agenda is heavy. Most councillors will not be allowed to speak. Their view will be represented by a single member of their party and the absolute limit on their time speaking will be 2 minutes, but more likely 1 minute. 

    Trafford has five political parties, each of which is allowed to submit a motion. All parties are allowed to submit an amendment to each of the other parties motions. Unlike Parliament, all amendments will be called and debated separately. There are a lot of amendments tomorrow night. 

    It will be a farce. It is a farce. There will not be meaningful debate. Each party will blame it on standing orders and the mayor, but they are incapable of making compromise to allow more time. 

    It adds to a growing democratic accountability problem in Trafford. What is most frustrating is the willingness of opposition parties to help the ruling group sidestep the level of debate and scrutiny that residents should expect from their elected representatives. 

    At present, and until something turns up (which I am, I may say, hourly expecting), I have nothing to bestow but advice. 

    Mr Micawber – David Copperfield by Charles Dickens 

  • September Executive Meeting

    September Executive Meeting

    If you’re looking for a window into decision making at Trafford Council, the Executive Meeting of the council is the best place to start.

    Whilst meetings of full council in the Town Hall chamber are designed for performative political bun fights, the meeting of the Executive at least ostensibly focuses on officer written reports requiring approval.

    I thought I’d write this piece as my previous post was on the single issue of the coming expiry of Sale Waterside’s PFI contract. That is but one of the agenda items at a busy first Executive meeting following the summer recess, and it’s certainly not the only matter of interest.

    So, other than the Waterside PFI, what’s on the agenda?

    Greater Manchester End to End Fostering Recruitment Hub

    Fostering is a critical element of Trafford’s children’s services. It was hard not to pick up this was also an area to which a lot of feedback was negative in terms of the reaction to Trafford’s inadequate rating.

    This report seeks Executive approval in principle for Trafford Council to participate in the Greater Manchester End-to-End Fostering Hub, which will expand the existing regional fostering recruitment hub into a service responsible for recruitment, assessment and approval of mainstream foster carers across Greater Manchester.

    The proposed model would transfer some fostering recruitment, assessment and approval functions to the Hub, whilst Trafford would retain responsibility for foster carer support and supervision, annual reviews, kinship fostering assessments and its wider statutory duties in relation to children in its care.


    Thoughts

    On the face of it, the project seems sensible. I would have liked formal input from the Trafford Foster Care Association. The report mentions that they’ve been briefed, but doesn’t provide any input from them. Given Ofsted’s judgement of Trafford’s provision as inadequate, it’s not reassuring for the report not to include user feedback.

    Corporate Plan Performance 25/26

    The council measures its performance against key indicators. These should really chart progress towards the Council Vision. I’m not a huge fan of corporate visions in general. Tom Ross and I took opposing positions on Trafford’s corporate vision.

    My view on the Trafford Vision

    If we cancelled every training session on corporate visions, it would be the easiest win on productivity we’re ever likely to make.

    Tom’s View

    Trafford – where all our residents, communities and businesses thrive

    I guess I was never a natural manager. I knew what a good piece of work was and it never seemed to need input from a corporate vision to enhance it.

    I’m being flippant, and even if Trafford’s seems vague and unobtainable, I’d still rather have it than Kellogg’s vision.

    A good and just world where people are not just fed but fulfilled.

    That’s Rice Krispies, right?

    I digress

    Back to Trafford, and I’m sure there’ll be some challenge from opposition parties on performance indicators in the red (below).

    • 16/17 Neet %
    • EHCP completion
    • Children referred for 2nd time Protection
    • Family Help re-referral rates
    • Early Years Attainment Gap
    • Improved conversion rate for Adults Safeguarding
    • Proportion of people using social care direct payments
    • Household Waste collected for Composting
    • Proportion of journeys undertaken by bike or on foot
    • Library loans
    • Staff sickness

    Link to Full report

    I always think these reports should be an opportunity to take a broad look across the council. For instance, it would be really useful for the executive not just to take stock of performance indicators, but things like staff morale and staff retention. Data is routinely collected and reported on within the NHS, but they rarely get beyond Employment committee in Trafford.

    Budget Monitoring

    Given that Trafford required a capitalisation directive from the Government to allow it borrow up to £12.6m to support the revenue budget it’s vital that a close eye is kept on spending this year.

    As it stands, Trafford is projected to overspend by £2.78m. It’s not untypical for this to be the case in September. They’ll want to keep an eye on it but it’s not the time for panic.

    Co-incidentally, Trafford has be awarded £7.5m by the Ministry of housing, community and local government (MHCLG) this week as part of a package to those councils who’ve had to apply for special arrangements to balance the budget. Ostensibly, it’s for efficiencies.

    In Trafford using better technology, including AI, to make services smarter and easier for residents. This includes moving to a modern, more reliable computer system that brings all the council’s information together in one place, so different teams can work together more easily and give people better support when they need it, such as when applying for services or reporting an issue.

    Trafford and IT systems is an interesting subject. I’ll believe in the modern AI powered modern computer system when I see it.

    Budget Monitoring Report

    Sustainable Transport & Environment Board

    This is a new committee. It’s long overdue. Trafford has never taken public transport seriously whilst council’s like Stockport and Bolton have seen it as absolutely key to prosperity.

    Trafford Park Business Improvement District

    Business Improvement Districts can be very successful if businesses in an area have shared vision for improving things within its boundary. They tend to work around town centres, but having one in Trafford Park would be really interesting if it got going. The idea’s been around for over a decade but maybe the time is right for it to proceed.

    Trafford Park Business Improvement District

    Elected Members Social Media Guide

    I thought councillors already had a social media guide. In any event, they’ve got one now.

    Link to Social Media Guide

    It’s perhaps a good moment to flag that I’ve been blocked by Trafford’s Conservatives on Facebook. I’m guessing this was for pointing out they were just wrong on council tax rises.

    They shouldn’t be blocking people for that if that’s why they’ve done it. It suggests they want to deliberately misinform. I rarely comment on Conservative posts unless they’ve put something that’s verifiably untrue, as in this case, or more pertinently, I agree with them.

    I think in twenty years, I’ve only blocked one person and I’ve only deleted when not to do so could get me into legal hot water.

    That said, even if it hasn’t happened to me, social media can be difficult and it can get out of hand.

    I still wouldn’t turn the clock back on it though. It’s still an incredibly useful way to engage.

    Other items

    There’s a couple of items that have been brought about by changes to national rules

    Renters’ Rights

    Planning Committee Reform – making more applications for officer determination. Losing the ability to call-in applications. You are going to see less applications going to committee. The council does not have a choice in this.

    What’s not coming to Executive committee

    I’m really shocked that the two critical inspections are not on this agenda. Whilst issues are already being dealt with, I would still expect the Executive to receive a formal report of the process.

    Executive Committee Behaviour

    Since Executive meetings are chaired by the Leader of the council they can be just as performative as the main council. We saw this last year that the meetings can be subject to the lowest of stunts, when opposition parties were subjected to having to deliver serious questions from a wobbly kitchen table. I’m just an ordinary resident now. I don’t want to see childish shenanigans from the leadership.

    I’d love your feedback

    I do this because I enjoy it, but that doesn’t mean I’m only interested in my point of view.

    Please tell me I’m right, tell me I’m wrong.

    Oh and don’t forget you can subscribe to an email whenever I post.

  • Sale Waterside to be bought out of the PFI

    Sale Waterside to be bought out of the PFI

    Sale Waterside is a well regarded suburban arts centre in Sale. The complex also includes Sale Library and a large amount of office space that is primarily used by Trafford Council. There’s also the (now closed) Slug and Lettuce and the Caldo Lounge.

    The complex was developed under a PFI arrangement and opened in 2004. The PFI arrangement to which Trafford entered into paid a charge to the contractor. This is coming to an end and the Trafford Council Executive has to take a decision

    The options are:

    Option A

    Exit the contract and take back the complex for the final “bullet” payment in the contract. Agree to purchase the 2 commercial units for their open market value.

    Option B

    Exit the PFI asset in October 2028, leaving the facility in the PFI contractor ownership.

    The Council has performed a financial analysis, including a valuation of the building, the exit payment and operating costs, and the recommendation is to take back the building and make the final payment to Equans. The recommendation is also to acquire the two commercial units at open market value. Details of this are outlined in the part 2 (restricted) report.

    Thoughts

    Even allowing for the fact that the commercial/financial data is closed to the public, it does feel as though only a shallow consideration has been taken.

    There’s apparently 400 council desks at Waterside. Is it in the council’s interest to maintain that. I’ve got to be honest, I was surprised by the number. Is it time to start consolidating our office space? I think we also need to ask the extent to which our presence is good for Sale Town Centre. This is a prime site in Sale. I am surprised that the vibrancy of this quarter has been allowed to slide.

    Clearly, I’m not questioning the presence of the library and theatre and it may be that the only way to ensure continuity is the purchase option. I’d be surprised if this was the case and that the library and theatre were part of this deal. They’re not explicitly mentioned. We’re over a barrel if they are!

    I think overall, I’d have liked scrutiny to take a broad look at the options before taking a decision. There’s a risk that back in Trafford’s ownership, we can’t maintain the premises to a standard that benefits Sale and we end up in a worse situation. These are not luxury offices. The risks mentioned in the report seem so superficial. It just seems a less than thorough options appraisal.

    I’d really be pleased to hear your thoughts on this as I think I’m just scratching at the surface.

    Sale Waterside Complex by N Chadwick, CC BY-SA 2.0 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

  • Extraordinary Council Meeting

    Extraordinary Council Meeting

    This was the meeting calling for resignations and self condemnation of pretty much everybody

    I previewed the meeting last week.

    The clash came to pass last night in the council chamber. Labour won. They had the votes.

    Most of the speakers were attacking Labour and a picture was painted of a Council Executive who were inward looking and lacking in curiosity.

    That narrative didn’t meet much challenge.

    My regret is that I’m still not actually sure how Trafford’s Executive were unaware that the issues highlighted in Ofsted’s opening paragraph had come about. I was hoping Children’s scrutiny the previous evening would have extracted something approaching a definitive answer. It would require some ‘first principle’ questioning.

    • How the ‘front door’ is monitored,
    • how failings would come to light,
    • how they are reported up the line

    All we have is the Ofsted verdict

    Since the previous inspection in 2022, when services in Trafford were judged as requires improvement to be good, leaders have been ineffective in recognising, prioritising and making improvements to some service shortfalls. Practice with children in care and for some care-experienced young people has improved, but there has been a serious deterioration in service areas, such as front door response.
    This has left some children at risk of harm.

    Leadership Culture

    I don’t think we’ll ever get a comprehensive answer to whether the culture set by Trafford’s political leadership played a part.

    The members of the Executive very much set themselves apart from the wider body of councillors. They don’t ask questions of wider councillors. They may have friendship groups to confide in, but it doesn’t seem to be a core value to be interested in the ward councillor’s perspective. This being the case, it hardly seems incongruous if there has been a lack of curiosity in terms of performance.

    There seems to be a culture of mutual comforting and reassurance amongst the cabinet. Consensus is reinforced. It would cause gross offense to demur.

    It is literally true that executive members challenging the consensus is now always in the past tense.

    This bias towards consensus permeates the council’s values

    I’ve never been a huge fan of Trafford’s ‘People Plan‘. Its EPIC Values have always seemed a little passively introverted to me, I’d like them to be more challenging, more focused on improvement.

    EPIC Values

    I almost think we hard-wired this failing into the culture. Still doesn’t explain everything, but I suggest that there are issues still to be solved beyond a simple change of personnel.

    The council meeting was interesting, we did get to hear the occasional line that set my alarms ringing;

    • “We’ve already dealt with”,
    • “Changes are in progress”,
    • “We’re going to be open, we don’t need to have a formal arrangement”

    We’ll have to see whether the Executive changes. I think one interesting consensus, certainly across the opposition parties, but I think into Labour backbenches was dissatisfaction with the scrutiny function. I hope that will be picked up.

    Link to Archived Video of the Proceedings on Youtube

    Overall, I think it was a worthwhile meeting. I don’t think resignations at this stage are a good idea, so I was happy with the way the votes went. It would be nice to think they take a broad view to some of the system failures that have taken place in my view, rather than the fault of a few individuals. And I’d really like the leaders to look in the mirror, have their behaviours contributed?

  • Council gets to lock horns over Children’s Service Failings

    Council gets to lock horns over Children’s Service Failings

    Previewing a big week for Trafford Council with Children’s Scrutiny on Tuesday and a full council on Wednesday.

    August is usually a quiet month for councillors, but two critical inspections have created a political crisis, and the Conservatives weren’t going to let this go without another vote of no confidence in Labour’s leader, Tom Ross.

    Conservative Motion

    It’s nearly 2500 words. That’s huge for a motion – 4 pages long.

    If you can’t face 2500 words, the motion can be split into two halves.

    First Half – What has happened

    The conservative motion opens with the historically correct reminder that in 2015 Trafford’s children’s services were judged to be ‘Good’ whilst under Conservative control.

    It goes on to say that subsequent reviews marked a decline (under Labour control) culminating in the current review.

    It criticises Trafford’s leadership (Labour’s) for not being on top of performance shortfalls throughout this time.

    Second Half – What is to be done about it

    The Conservatives say the council should:

    • Record its profound concern and apologise to children and families
    • Thank its frontline officers and foster carers
    • Recognise the record as representing a serious failure of governance and accountability
    • Declare a loss of confidence in its political leadership
    • Call on the leader (Tom Ross)to resign
    • Call on the Council Executive to recognise its part in this and look to restoring confidence in political oversight
    • Establish an independently chaired Children’s Services Improvement and Assurance Board
    • Require the administration to publish an improvement plan with regular reports to children’s scrutiny
    • Require a specific report into failings in the ‘front door’ to children’s services and the failures in oversight.
    • Look for commonalities in the preparation for each of the negative Ofsted reports
    • Receive a further report at full council as to progress
    • Affirm that it’s about day to day standards not just for Ofsted

    Thoughts on the motion

    This is a better motion than we’re used to from the Conservatives and I suspect they’ve had some help. It gets a little bit messy towards the end by being too prescriptive, but overall it does what the Conservatives want it to do.

    Labour’s response

    I really expected Labour to take a position that the Conservatives had rushed to produce a purely political motion when the seriousness of the situation called for a measured approach that had already begun. I expected them to simply vote against this motion. Instead, they’ve made amendments.

    I’m really surprised how much of the Conservative Motion survives amendment. It leaves a lot of the tale intact.

    Additional Points inserted by Labour’s Amendment

    The narrative history in the first half of the motion is tweaked to include a number of mitigating factors.

    • The budget for Children’s Services was reduced by the Conservatives after the ‘Good’ Ofsted
    • Within the latest ‘Inadequate’ Ofsted there some recognition of improvements in specific areas, notably report writing and support for children subject to protection plans
    • There had been a 60% increase in demand in the past 12 months
    • Ofsted recognised corporate and political commitment to children and that there had been additional investment
    • The ‘Expert Advisor’ being sent in by the Dept for Education as a consequence of the ‘Inadequate judgement’ will have a positive diagnostic input

    The above points are quite reasonable inclusions. It leaves the basic narrative intact. However, one of the smallest amendments in that first section is perhaps the most controversial.

    In 2026, Ofsted again found that leaders did not fully understand the scale of serious problems until inspectors arrived and did not possess a wholly accurate self-assessment of service quality and impact.

    is amended to

    In 2026, Ofsted again found that service leaders did not fully understand the scale of serious problems until inspectors arrived and did not possess a wholly accurate self-assessment of service quality and impact.

    The Ofsted report does not distinguish between service leaders, corporate leaders or political leaders. I really don’t like this particular amendment, leaders should stand with their teams, not washing their hands of them. I’m not impressed at all by this amendment and perhaps it highlights bigger issues.

    Amendments to the 2nd half of the Conservative motion

    They add some new measures

    • Recognise the record as representing a serious failure of governance and accountability
      (is softened)

    The amendment deletes the paragraphs criticising the council leadership and executive.

    It adds some new measures

    • Seek support from an independent improvement partner through a local authority that demonstrated outstanding practice in Children’s Services
    • Bring tangible and practical improvements to partnership working in Trafford including partners in health and Greater Manchester Police.
    • Calls on all partners in Trafford to recognise the challenge and allocate and identify dedicated and consistent resources to Trafford and the new Improvement Board.

    Labour has the numbers, if its councillors turn up

    This will be one of those meetings that will have the strongest of three-line-whips. It used to always be impressed on new councillors that there may come a time when councillors are expected to fly home early for important votes. It actually did happen famously about thirty years ago with regard to Greater Manchester’s Public Transport Authority when the votes across the councils of GM were almost in balance.

    I think we’re slightly softer these days, but it’s hard to see how an executive member could stay in post if they miss Wednesday’s vote.

    Had I still been a councillor, I would have supported the Labour Leadership and voted for their amendments. I would have blamed the leadership for their lack of openness. I would have told them in the corridor they’d brought this on themselves, but I would still have voted for them. I’m glad to be out of it.

    It needs stating

    There needs to be changes in how Labour’s leadership in Trafford operates. They’ve been found wanting.

    Scrutiny

    Scrutiny of Trafford’s approach to the Ofsted verdict is actually the day before council. Sadly, it’s just a verbal presentation. Whilst it will be worth watching on Youtube, its hard to see how much input scrutiny is going to be allowed to make. I hope I’m wrong.

  • Not Good – Inspections of key services confirm Trafford’s worst fears

    Not Good – Inspections of key services confirm Trafford’s worst fears

    Adult and Children’s inspection Reports across Greater Manchester

    Adult Social CareChildren’s Services
    BoltonGoodFeb26GoodSep23
    BuryGoodJun26Requires ImprovementJun25
    ManchesterGoodAug26OutstandingOct25
    OldhamGoodFeb26GoodMay24
    RochdaleGoodJun26Requires ImprovementFeb23
    SalfordInadequateMay26GoodNov23
    StockportGoodMay26Requires ImprovementMay25
    TamesideRequires ImprovementJun26InadequateDec23
    TraffordRequires ImprovementAug26InadequateJun26
    WiganOutstandingMar26GoodOct25

    Trafford has found itself in the unenviable position of receiving two critical inspection reports in quick succession. There’s been a political furore and urgent meetings in the middle of August have had to be scheduled.

    Adult Social Services

    Because all of Greater Manchester’s Adult Services have been inspected in quick succession, I think it’s useful to compare these across Greater Manchester.

    Most of our neighbours have been rated as ‘Good’.

    Wigan are rated as ‘Outstanding’.

    Salford have been given an ‘Inadequate’ mark.

    That leaves Tameside and Trafford as ‘Requiring Improvement’.

    Children’s Services

    The inspections into Children’s Services have been taking place over a much longer period going back to 2023. Trafford is the only Greater Manchester Council that’s had an inspection this year. Trafford’s Children’s Services have been rated as inadequate.

    The opening paragraph of the inspection report is corruscating.

    Since the previous inspection in 2022, when services in Trafford were judged as requires improvement to be good, leaders have been ineffective in recognising, prioritising and making improvements to some service shortfalls.

    Practice with children in care and for some care-experienced young people has improved, but there has been a serious deterioration in service areas, such as front door response. This has left some children at risk of harm.

    This is serious. Yes, there’s some positive comments in sections of the report, but those opening paragraphs are damning.


    But surely Tameside is in the same place as Trafford?

    It’s true that Tameside has received the same combination, but the three year time lapse has made it noticeably less febrile there. Maybe, that’s somewhat unfair, but we can’t make Tameside react differently.

    So, where does that leave us?

    Trafford have issued a public response to the Ofsted report.

    Work is already under way to strengthen children’s services.

    … improving decision-making and management oversight at the Front Door, where contacts and referrals are first received and assessed…

    …focusing on specific areas identified in the inspection, the response to children at risk of significant harm, safety planning, support for 16 and 17 year old homeless children, young carers…

    Democratic oversight will be provided by the Children’s Scrutiny Committee.

    I welcome the involvement of Scrutiny. Shirley Procter as chair of Children’s scrutiny has a wealth of experience of children’s services. There is no one better to run with this.

    However, I can’t help reflecting on the council’s suspension of all scrutiny for a big part of last year. I hope the leadership will reflect on their tendency to close down oversight whenever there’s opportunity. I suspect scrutiny would have brought some of these issues to the fore ahead of Ofsted.

    The speed with which questioning of the Executive was suppressed during the Mayoral election suggests the openness promised in the response may not be observed in practice. This is not a council executive characterised by its inclusive governance.

    The Extraordinary Council Meetings

    The Council Meeting will take place on the 26th August, the meeting of Children’s scrutiny precedes it on the 25th. Of the two, the scrutiny is likely to be by far the more constructive. It really depends how open the Executive is to its shortcomings, and to the extent to which it is receptive to advice.

    The Conservatives have already made it clear that they are pursuing the resignation of the Labour Leader, Tom Ross, at the Council Meeting.

    Is there a case for resignations?

    The objective argument is whether the resignation of the leader allows a more proactive examination of how to deliver these services to the required standard.

    I don’t think one ought to be sentimental about this. I’ve seen leaders hang on when circumstances conspire. It’s the party that loses as a consequence.

    A shift to inclusivity might well entail some changes to personnel. However, I don’t think it will happen. In fact, the Tory approach makes even less likely to happen. The council will divide on party lines and the leadership will receive a vote of confidence.

    That potential vote of confidence is troubling. You can’t draw a simple line under a verdict that ‘there has been a serious deterioration in service areas, such as front door response. This has left some children at risk of harm.’

    I would prefer the Conservatives to avoid a vote on resignations. They are entitled to make capital. It ought to be an opportunity for constructive input.

    Can we be assured that the risk of harm will be mitigated?

    The inspection has provoked a response across social media from carers and young people that have interacted with children’s services. I wouldn’t call it an explosion, but there’s certainly been some.

    We really need the voices of people who’ve been engaged with Children’s Services to be heard. They won’t be served by a political bun fight and obfuscation.

    We really need to be shining a light on how things are put right. The risk is that the opposite will happen and the matter is locked down.