Category: Finance

  • Autumn Reflection

    Autumn Reflection

    It’s been a little while since I posted. Rehabilitation from a planned heart operation is progressing well. It’s not been pain-free, but the worst is over. I even (briskly) walked Kingsway Parkrun on Saturday.

    It’s six months since I stepped down as a councillor. It’s still good to be free, but I still live in Trafford. I still care about the place and still care about the services we have. 

    Those six months have been dominated by a few issues that are coming to a head in the autumn period: 

    Critical Ofsted inspection of Children’s Services 

    I want to give a brief summary of how it’s being addressed as far as we know. 

    Trafford’s finances  

    In hourly expectation of something turning up, Trafford’s leadership has said it doesn’t want Exceptional Finance Support to balance its books this coming year. Given that Trafford relies on Council Tax more than its neighbours, I think the clearance to raise the rate a little more should not be rejected so easily.

    RankLocal AuthorityBand D 2026/27
    1Stockport£2,618.90
    2Oldham£2,602.23
    3Rochdale£2,600.83
    4Salford£2,594.45
    5Bury£2,555.15
    6Tameside£2,447.21
    7Bolton£2,399.74
    8Manchester£2,312.04
    9Trafford£2,291.70
    10Wigan£2,152.68

     

    Council Meeting Arrangements – Are Trafford’s council meetings doing their job?  

    (spoiler alert) No! And they’re getting worse. 

    This is my opportunity to have a go at Trafford’s opposition parties. Why are they allowing it to happen?

    Children’s Services

    Ofsted’s rating for Trafford’s Children’s Services was Inadequate. This rating led to a political furore. Opposition parties called for an emergency meeting of council on the 26th August at which they called a vote of no confidence in Trafford’s leader of the council, Tom Ross. The opposition parties didn’t have sufficient votes to win the no confidence vote against the Labour majority, but they did manage to muster unity across the four parties; Conservatives, Lib Dems, Greens and Reform that they’d lost faith in Tom. 

    In outvoting the combined opposition vote, the Labour group managed to navigate the rocky political waters charged by the damning report, but it wasn’t a comfortable night. It has to be said that it wasn’t a particularly well informed night. The Conservatives charge was that in 2015 under their leadership, Children’s Services received an ‘Outstanding Rating’. Labour countered that a lot of money had been pulled by the Conservatives since then. The debate rarely got beyond the superficial point-scoring.  

    Children’s Services were never my expertise, but my understanding is that Trafford Council knew Ofsted were coming for an inspection and were not anticipating the criticism that was heading their way. A lot, maybe even the majority of areas had indeed improved since their last inspection. The problem area was what they call the ‘front door’. This is the pathway into the system. Referrals can come from the police, schools, families, the young person self-referring etc. It’s the most critical element within the system. 

    Jill McGregor, until recently Corporate Director of Children’s Services, acknowledged that they hadn’t been sufficiently curious in drilling down how the front door was performing in different scenario during their pre-Ofsted preparation. Ofsted came in June 2026 at a moment of peak demand. Looking at the figures, it does seem to have been freakishly high demand. That said, their procedures and protocols should have been able to cope and they should not have been overwhelmed. Ofsted found that there were young people put at risk by delays, wrong pathways and the system underperforming. I don’t know whether the freak increase in demand broke the system whilst Ofsted were watching, but it’s clear it should not have broken. 

    Jill McGregor has left her post. The emphasis has shifted from understanding what went wrong to building a system that would have met Ofsted’s requirements in June 26. It’s fairly predictable and I’m sure it will work as a short term remedy.

    My gut feeling is that we need to give greater emphasis on driving performance from the top. Trafford’s leadership both on the political side and in terms of the senior corporate leadership is tilted very much towards toward the super-sized Lego set aspects of council activity. It’s understandable that regionally important projects such as the stadium district and Carrington should get the attention of the leadership. The photo-opportunities of topping-out ceremonies in hard-hats and hi-vis, not to mention trips to Monaco, do amount to the glamourous side of local politics. However, I do think there’s a need to strengthen the leadership of the more prosaic performance aspects. Our chief executive, Sara Todd, was not challenged at all by scrutiny as regards to her oversight of the corporate leadership in Children’s Services. It has to be said Environmental Services got a very easy ride from scrutiny when they were before them the other week. It leaves the impression that services that operate on a day to day basis don’t get the attention they merit until something goes wrong.

    I would advocate appointing a second deputy leader to work alongside Tom Ross and Liz Patel to drive performance improvement. I think they need the status to drive this agenda in the corporate leadership team. In terms of spend, adult, children and environmental operations account for the bulk of spending, but they’re not receiving sufficient status within the council’s hierarchy. Both Manchester and Salford councils have two deputy leaders each, so I don’t believe it’s an outrageous proposal and I am convinced there’s sufficient talent within the Labour Group to deliver someone who can really raise performance within the council’s main departments whilst working alongside Tom and Liz. 

    Trafford’s Finances

    The latest report on how we’re coping in the current year came before the Council’s Executive yesterday.

    We’re half-way through the current year and we’re heading for a £6m overspend. There will be actions to try to bring this figure down, but it is on top of the £12m that Trafford was already borrowing to set the budget. 

    Listening to Monday’s Executive meeting. I’m not sensing there’s panic. There is mention of a £7.5m grant that does seem to have been pulled out of a hat by the Government to target councils receiving exceptional financial support. I didn’t see that coming, so there may be more. My biggest worry is meeting budget requirements via long-term debt. That debt is mounting. 

    We’ll see. The council are currently recruiting a successor to our Financial Officer, Graeme Bentley who is retiring. You’d assume that new finance officer would be looking to get things on a stable footing as quickly as possible. Graeme is an excellent officer and this isn’t how he’d want to leave things. I don’t think we can live in hope that something will turn up.

    Council Meetings

    Let’s keep this one short. Meetings of councillors have become rubbish and it’s the fault of councillors.  

    Tomorrow night’s meeting is scheduled to commence at 7pm and to finish at 9:30pm. 

    The agenda is heavy. Most councillors will not be allowed to speak. Their view will be represented by a single member of their party and the absolute limit on their time speaking will be 2 minutes, but more likely 1 minute. 

    Trafford has five political parties, each of which is allowed to submit a motion. All parties are allowed to submit an amendment to each of the other parties motions. Unlike Parliament, all amendments will be called and debated separately. There are a lot of amendments tomorrow night. 

    It will be a farce. It is a farce. There will not be meaningful debate. Each party will blame it on standing orders and the mayor, but they are incapable of making compromise to allow more time. 

    It adds to a growing democratic accountability problem in Trafford. What is most frustrating is the willingness of opposition parties to help the ruling group sidestep the level of debate and scrutiny that residents should expect from their elected representatives. 

    At present, and until something turns up (which I am, I may say, hourly expecting), I have nothing to bestow but advice. 

    Mr Micawber – David Copperfield by Charles Dickens 

  • Budget 26 – the fallout

    Budget 26 – the fallout

    Trafford’s 26/27 budget passed its final hurdle when it was approved by council. It was a dreadful meeting that you can watch here in all its glory on YouTube:

    https://www.youtube.com/live/MUVmRcbQjWw?si=NSBS4Tzz5YQ_zxOG

    • The Conservatives accepted the plan to borrow up to £12.6m to support the budget for the year, but verbally rejected the need to increase council tax above the 4.99% ceiling. (There was some knockabout debate about whether their motion did indeed limit the council tax rise, but they were definitely prepared to borrow.)
    • The Lib Dems took the view that since we were nowhere near a balanced budget without borrowing, the finance officer should declare bankruptcy under section 114 and demand government intervention.
    • The Greens accepted the budget, but because they oppose the relief road in Carrington (although it’s not in the budget), they would vote against the budget.

    I voted for the budget and did so unreservedly. It’s my view that the Council Leadership and their officers have correctly held their nerve against further cuts to services and resolved to pressure for a fairer settlement.

    What made it a really poor debate was that the architects of our misfortune were almost completely left out of the debate.

    I remain a Labour man and will always try to defend their choices, but the Government’s finance settlement is ludicrously miscued. They have rightly targeted areas of higher levels of deprivation for extra funding, but they’ve sourced that funding from middling council areas. Places like Trafford, Warrington and Crewe have all been pushed into taking out huge loans to support day to day spending. Not so long ago, councillors who voted for such budgets would have been personally surcharged. Now government wants us put our budget on the tick and it barely gets a mention.

    Northwest Councils requiring borrowing to support revenue.

    If you cross the River Mersey in the right places you can travel from Southport to Worcestershire on a continuous route through boroughs receiving the same punishment beating as Trafford.

    I’m no fan of Morgan McSweeney’s friend, the Maga hat wearing Steve Reed, who is the Local Government minister that targeted the North West’s commuter belt, but surely he can see these places are not just the homes of premier league footballers, but contain levels of deprivation and isolation just as chronic as inner-cities. We need to get angry.

    What happens now?

    I suppose it’s easy for me stamping my feet. Trafford’s leadership has to continue to make the case through the normal channels and to seek Greater Manchester support, even assistance. I’d like to see us making a more collective call with the other councils, particularly those in the North West.

    The Conservative Party are moving a no-confidence motion at Council tonight that sounds like it’s been dictated to by a caller to Talk Radio. It’s all over the place. It will be a farcical debate that will be lucky to get 15 minutes granted to it. The financial management of the council is the wrong thing to take on, and in any event, we’re about 7 weeks from an election, where the public decide their backing for the council.

    Thankfully, I won’t be able to attend tonight’s council meeting, but the Conservatives really ought to pull that motion. It’s just a rant from them.

    Finally,

    So, this is really the last piece on Budget 26. I’ve enjoyed writing the articles. They’ve helped me focus and try to unpick a budget that wasn’t afforded the level of scrutiny that should be mandatory. That said, the budget that eventually was revealed to councillors is probably the right one. There’ll be a tweak here or there that I’d make, but I don’t think it’s massively wrong.

    However, whilst the budget may have emerged from this intact, the democratic mechanics in Trafford have broken and the checks that should enable input from outside the Council Executive and Corporate Leadership simply aren’t functioning. The closedown of council for two by-elections held in quick succession took away 80% of the time normally allotted to budget scrutiny and had no basis in guidance. That is serious.

    Just as serious is the lack of public engagement. The community knows that consultation has become a word that the council uses that has no relation to its English meaning. Not so long ago the trajectory was towards co-production of budgets with participation. It’s gone backwards during my time as councillor.

    The public have declining confidence in those low-level spending decisions, which roads get prioritised, which parks, where ‘hubs’ are located. This may be the right budget for Trafford, but I doubt the public will believe that it will be administered fairly. They see where money is spent and where it is not spent, but explanations are never easily available and cynicism is a natural consequence.

    Councils are not overlords. We as councillors are representatives of the electors, and officers are agents of that representation. We’ve got to allow public into decisions on how their council tax is spent.

    Last words

    It’s a god-awful settlement from government on how much of the money raised in Trafford can be spent in Trafford. There’s not much else that can be said.

    image: Steve Reed Lauren Hurley / No 10 Downing Street, OGL 3 http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/version/3, via Wikimedia Commons

  • Setting Trafford’s Budget Pt 8 The Budget is published.

    Setting Trafford’s Budget Pt 8 The Budget is published.

    The Final Budget has been published, ready to be put to council on the 5th March.

    Trafford Council Budget 2026-27.

    In terms of spending choices, as one would expect there’s not a huge difference from the draft budget released in January. The proposed net budget is £274m compared to the £277m originally projected, which is good. It’s about the only good thing on show.

    We knew that the Government had determined that we needed to be able to increase Council Tax by an additional 2.5% compared to the standard rise. That 7.5% is therefore built into this final budget.

    We’ve been granted the facility to borrow £12.64m for the coming year. This is on top of borrowing £9.6m or thereabouts for the year that’s coming to an end.

    Borrowing is not routine, it’s a seismic change.

    The act of borrowing to support day to day spending has always been outlawed and rightly so! I don’t like it at all. Fundamentally, it’s borrowing from future budgets. It’s particularly worrying when future finances do not look any rosier.

    Given this is a three year settlement, you would hope we could see light at the end of the tunnel, but there’s no sign yet of a balanced budget, albeit there is a narrowed gap in 2028.

    I learn from the local democracy reporting service that Sefton is looking to a fire sale of assets to balance its budget. This seems to require Government permission.

    Liverpool Echo Sefton selling off assets to balance budget

    Trafford hasn’t committed using receipts from its land sales. However, the land sales plan routinely contains the paragraph:

    Receipts generated from the disposal of sites as detailed in Category 1 and returns from development of sites detailed in Category 2 are currently earmarked to directly support the Capital Programme, although these could also be used to support the wider strategic management of Council borrowing.

    They’ve not used receipts before, as far as I am aware, to support the management of borrowing, but we’ve never been in this position.

    The more I think of Trafford, Warrington, Cheshire East and Sefton, the angrier I get on their behalf. I can’t believe how passively we’re all accepting this absolutely dreadful settlement from Government.

    Yes, there’s an argument that our council tax level in Trafford is somewhat adrift from what it really ought to be to deliver the standard of service people want, but the comparison with Manchester’s settlement is just too extreme. The difference that’s going to become apparent between Old Trafford and Whalley Range is so unjustifiable it needs to be screamed at Government. I’m appalled.

    Budget Documents

    The 26/27 Final Budget Proposals (109) pages
    Key Parts –
    Report of the Director of Finance and Systems on the
    Robustness of the Proposed Budget Estimates and the
    Adequacy of Financial Reserves (Page 9)
    Financial Background (Page 33)
    The Budget – Page 59
    Savings Proposals – Page 86

    Capital Spending

    Treasury Management (Debt and Reserves)

    Fees, Charges and Allowances (everything from parking to cremation charges)

    Budget Scrutiny Response These are the executive’s answers to the recommendations of the scrutiny committee.
    (The Scrutiny don’t seem to have been given access to questions over financing the budget gap. It’s certainly not raised.)
    Given that effective scrutiny was particular emphasis of the peer review of Trafford, I don’t know that this serves Trafford.

  • How are other councils doing?

    How are other councils doing?

    What have we done to deserve this?

    The Government’s settlement for local government has left some councils in a desperate situation, whilst others are busily working out how they’re going to spend the extra money.

    I don’t have to be polite. This is a ridiculous way to proceed. You’re not going to get value for money at either extreme.

    Nevertheless, we’re in the spotlight. Are we going to get a visit from the Government inspector? The Bishop of Bath and Wells?Are we on our own?

    It’s bleak for us.

    So, what about the councils around us?

    Manchester

    Core Spending Power increases from £786m to £874m, an 11.2% increase. This core spending power equates to £1438 per person.

    The budget papers go to scrutiny on Monday 23rd February.

    They’re very pleased!

    This is a positive settlement for Manchester, by 2028/29 the Council’s overall CSP is forecast to be around 32% higher in cash terms and 24.2% higher in real terms then 2025/26. After accounting for projected population growth this translates to an average 22.9% real terms increase in funding per resident.

    Salford

    Core Spending Power increases from £399m to £424m, a 6.3% increase. This core spending equates to £1431 per person, not a great deal less than Manchester’s.

    The budget goes to cabinet tomorrow 17th February. They’re very pleased!

    This settlement marks a fundamental shift in local government funding, with significant redistribution,
    new formulas, and a move towards consolidated grants. This settlement will result in the most significant redistribution of funding within the sector in the last 25 years.

    Warrington

    Continuing anti-clockwise around Trafford’s border we come to Warrington. Like Trafford, Warrington has been allowed to increase its council tax by 7.99%.

    Core spending increases from £237m to £242m, a 4.5% increase. This figure is calculated before the extra 2.5% council tax is applied, but it’s noteworthy that the increase in core spending is already less than the increase in council tax. This core spending equates to £1109 per person, substantially down on Manchester and Salford.

    Their budget plan goes to scrutiny tonight (16th February). There’s an open acknowledgement they’re in serious difficulty. Their 3 year budget gap has increased from £90m to £130m since December.

    It’s fair to say they’re in a perilous position as their cabinet member for finance explains in the accompanying press release.

    This is almost a confessional to a person holding a hot poker.

    The reports published today detail that our difficulties stem from inadequate budget control, an over-ambitious commercial approach, and several years of unaudited accounts.

    We are victim to national issues, such as rising demands and costs for some services, particularly services that support our young people, families and older adults.

    But specific local issues have also played a significant role in driving our budget issues.

    In recent years, instead of making difficult service cuts when many other councils did, we have relied heavily on income generated from our commercial activity. And, while our commercial portfolio has provided a surplus of around £166 million since 2009, all of this money has been used towards covering successive budget gaps.

    Cllr Denis Matthews, Cabinet Member for Finance, Warrington Council

    Cheshire East

    Continuing our trip around the councils that border Trafford, we come to Cheshire East. Their town hall is based in Macclesfield, but the local authority area comes right up to the outskirts of Altrincham. Cheshire East is in the unenviable position of having a request to increase its council tax refused by government. They wanted a 9% increase but have not been granted any dispensation beyond the standard 4.99%. Politically, they’re facing a vote of no confidence.

    Core Spending Power increases from £430m to £452m, a 5.2% increase. This core spending power equates to £1062 per person.

    Cheshire East are recognising that even with Government support via EFS this is a difficult position.

    The section 151 officer issued the following statement of assurance on the authority’s financial position:

    Assurance Statement of the Chief Financial Officer

    1. The risks in the 2026/27 budget are predominantly in relation to costs associated with demand in Adult and Children Social Care, the delivery of the Improvement and Transformation programme and the Council’s position on the DSG deficit.
    2. Moreover, the inadequate level of general reserves will require the Council to continue to rely on the provision of EFS in order to balance the budget for 2026/27 and future years.
    3. This is not a financially sustainable position and the financial challenges for the Council remain acutely difficult. It is only with the support of EFS that the
      Council can set a balanced budget and this is not a sustainable position.

    Trafford

    Core Spending Power increases from £247m to £251m, an exceptionally paltry 1.9% increase. This core spending power equates to £1041 per person which is the lowest of all these councils.

    The draft budget is due to be published tonight. Of the four councils that border Trafford, two are in a parlous position and two are in clover.

    Trafford has by far the lowest financial spend of the five councils, yet it collects the most per person when you add in business rate collection.

    Some of the negative comments I’ve seen on social media about the financial challenge are a disgrace and there’s a significant political opportunism from people that should know better.

    Trafford’s predicament is not one of a spendthrift council. One might argue that council tax was so low that it prevented sufficient flexibility in the reserves.

    The graph below shows how Trafford has always lagged its neighbours in terms of council tax. Note the uppermost plot is the England average. All these local rates are lower than the average.

    AI generated image by the author using Gemini

  • Setting Trafford’s Budget Pt 7

    Setting Trafford’s Budget Pt 7

    My previous post on setting the budget ended with the words,

    Over to the Government

    All options are possible: worse, same or getting better.

    Fingers crossed.

    This was the week we found out.

    Monday – I hate Mondays

    The final settlement for most local authorities was published.

    The key figure is the 1.9% increase in core spending power. This is based on Council Tax increasing by 4.99%. Yet local budget pressures are increasing by 18.81%. There’s a considerable gap.

    The Govt recognised that the ceiling of 4.99% on council tax increases would place Trafford in an extremely difficult position and has consequently granted the facility to make an additional increase of 2.5%.

    It’s at this point that the proverbial hit the fan. The fact that Trafford is one of a small number councils requiring this facility has shocked residents. Social Media has been on fire. It’s not been pleasant.

    It’s hard to disagree with lots of these comments. The council tax increase is not going to result in notable improvements to service. The truth is that we’ve been hit by changes to the formula used by government to determine the distribution of centrally held funds.

    Areas with high levels of deprivation have benefited from both increases to core funding and a recovery grant that’s given a substantial pick-me-up to most of our neighbouring councils. Only Stockport along with ourselves have missed out. Stockport has a much, much higher council tax with which to absorb this discrepancy. Trafford’s low council tax has kept us lean, but it’s left us incredibly exposed in facing this perfect storm.

    We’re going to have borrow

    This really worries me. We were given facility to borrow £9.6m to support this year’s budget, and it looks like we’ll be utilising most of it. We’re awaiting news of what the government proposes the facility will be for next year, but it could be more than last year.

    I’m standing down in May and I hate the idea that I’m passing debt onto my successors because we didn’t have enough to pay for day to day spending. We’ve surely got to do as much as we can to limit this borrowing.

    If we were able to set our council tax to the average level, we’d be able to avoid borrowing, but that would require an increase of about 17%. Despite it being the normal rate elsewhere, Trafford residents would not weather an extra 17% increase.

    So where does that leave us?

    Councillors will have to take the hit what is really an unsatisfactory compromise – unwelcome increases in council tax, a level of service that doesn’t meet expectations and increased risk of much worse as the debts begin to accumulate.

  • Getting tetchy!

    Getting tetchy!

    I read a really good piece in the Manchester Evening News by Hannah Richardson. It captured perfectly the mood of Trafford Council.

    The Conservatives blamed Labour, Labour blamed the Conservatives, and the Greens pointed the finger at every other party present.

    Hannah Richardson MEN

    We’re still waiting for the Government’s decision. It normally lands by the end of January, so everyone’s feeling a bit on edge.

    Somerset Council has already had to postpone their budget meetings in the absence of the final settlement.

    One can imagine that the team led by Nico Heslop (Director of Finance) at MHCLG has had its work cut out in listening to the protestations of councils like Trafford over the proposed settlement.

    My guess is that we will learn our fate this week. It will be good to channel all this nervous energy into constructive activity.

    The Conservatives as main opposition party will want to put an alternative budget forward. The other parties might want to propose tweaks. They clearly need to see the Labour budget first.

    If the law dictates that it all has to be done and dusted by March 11, we really need that final settlement agreed.

    Link to Manchester Evening News Article on the Council Meeting of 28 January 2026